In Motion: Not So Ill with You and Me by Fani Papageorgiou (Shearsman Books, 2015)

Adam Day
| Reviews

 

One senses in these lines the pressures on the self and on our imaginative capacities under the ossifying influences of late capitalism everywhere present in Papgeorgiou’s verse. She sees the self-imposed nature of many of those pressures and is mindful of the limitations of particular historical moments. Problems of agency, disappearance, evasion, potential misperception, self-deception, inconstancy, resignation, a dialogue between ambivalence and urgency—they all strike one as similar in tone and atmosphere to Antonioni’s 1960 L’Avventura, where absence is a compelling presence. The film’s central character, Anna (Lea Massari), vanishes during a trip with a group of friends to the Mediterranean island of Panarea, and most of the film consequently centers around that absence, working—as does Not So Ill with You and Me—as a form of documentation not only of the pain and distress Anna’s vanishing creates, but of the gaps her disappearance uncovers in the lives of those connected to her.

In Not So Ill with You and Me events simply occur, with Papageorgiou making the reader aware that those events would have no significance or would have lost their significance, if not for the speaker analyzing and commenting upon them, implicitly raising the question of how we signal events as significant or not, and the role of art in doing so. People in these poems often seem not to function actively; rather, they simply move, or exist:

 

We can be pollen

preserved in lake sediments,

old cranes by the waterfront,

but nothing has to happen

for it to be life.

 

The risk of poems so deeply focused on voice is that the voice must be that much more reliable; when it falters, the effect is compounded by Papageourgiou’s heavy use of the second person. While the “you” can be quite engaging, at times it is likely to provoke resistance in the reader, who seems to be already spoken for. This isn’t helped when “you” appears in a line like “Wherever you go,/there you are.”

Adam Day is author of Model of a City in Civil War (Sarabande, 2015), and is the recipient of a PSA Chapbook Fellowship and a PEN Emerging Writers Award. He directs The Baltic Writing Residency in Sweden, Scotland, and Bernheim Forest.

Next
RadioStay: Stay by Kathleen McGookey (Press 53, 2015); Radioland by Lesley Wheeler (Barrow Street Press, 2015)
Previous
Between Lives: Cities I’ve Never Lived In: Stories by Sara Majka (Graywolf Press, 2016)